Skip to main content

← Mayor

Compare candidates

Mayor

4 candidates for 1 seat

Everyone is compared on the same 12 issues, in the same order. Candidates are listed alphabetically, and the order of issues is not a ranking. How this works.

Taxes, spending and value for money

What happens to my tax bill, and where does the money go?

This candidate has spoken about this issue more than once. Each statement is shown with its own source.

Full financial and governance review before new spending; won't promise no tax increases, but promises harder questions and explaining where money goes.

  • Control municipal spending and improve efficiencies.
  • Undertake a comprehensive financial and governance review.
  • Says he will ask harder questions before Council spends or raises taxes.
  • Will not promise to eliminate every tax increase.
  • Promises harder questions before spending more or raising taxes.
  • Wants residents to understand where the money goes.
“Control municipal spending, improve efficiencies, and recognize the financial pressures facing residents, families, and businesses. I'm not promising that we can eliminate every tax increase or solve every problem overnight. I am promising that I will ask harder questions. Before we spend more, I want to know why we need to spend it. Before we raise taxes, I want residents to understand where that money is going.”

(several paragraphs)

Source: Dan Armour campaign website — Platform · September 13, 2026

Governance and financial review (last done 2012); claims staff found over $300,000, turning a $250,000 deficit into a $150,000 surplus.

  • Wants a governance and financial review; the last was in 2012, 'three mayors ago'.
  • Claims managers found over $300,000 in four months.
  • Claims a projected $250,000 deficit became a $150,000 surplus.
“One of the first things we need to do is governance and financial review. The last time one was done was in 2012, that's three mayors ago. We were originally coming in with about a $250,000 deficit, but after talking to staff and having the managers go back to their budgets, when we finished we were $150,000 to the good. So they found over $300,000 in four months.”

(a few sentences)

Source: Sept 17, 2026 mayoral debate, Algonquin Theatre — candidate's own remarks (0:28:48) · September 17, 2026

Describes his platform as a return to basics: taxes, transparency and accountability.

  • Says he is prepared to undertake both a governance review and a financial review.
  • Spoken at the Chamber meet-and-greet, 9 September 2026.
“We need to start looking after our own. We need to start listening more, be more transparent, and stop the burden of taxes on all our constituents”

(reported remarks)

Source: Huntsville Doppler — Mayoral candidates make their pitch at Chamber meet and greet (event 9 Sep 2026) · September 11, 2026

Think we’ve got this wrong?

This candidate has spoken about this issue more than once. Each statement is shown with its own source.

Priorities: responsible spending, health-care readiness, better infrastructure, strong core services, a stronger Huntsville voice at the District; real value for every tax dollar.

  • Responsible spending, health care readiness, better infrastructure, strong core services.
  • A stronger voice for Huntsville at the District.
  • Taxpayers should see real value for every dollar spent.
“My priorities are responsible spending, health care readiness, better infrastructure, strong core services, and stronger voice for Huntsville at district. I will listen to residents, plan responsibly for future generations, and make decisions that protect what makes Huntsville home while ensuring taxpayers see real value for every dollar spent.”

(reported remarks)

Source: What mayoral candidates in Muskoka's three largest towns say they want to change (MuskokaRegion) · September 28, 2026

Responsible spending means setting priorities and showing residents the value.

  • Reduce waste, find efficiencies, set clear priorities.
  • Argues major expenses should not catch the Town off guard.
“Every tax dollar comes from someone’s hard work. That should matter every time a decision is made.”

(several paragraphs)

Source: Dan Caswell campaign website — My Priorities · September 13, 2026

Every tax dollar comes from someone's hard work; responsible spending means clear priorities, less waste, efficiencies, and visible value for money.

  • Every tax dollar comes from someone's hard work.
  • Responsible spending: clear priorities, reduced waste, efficiencies.
  • Residents should see real value from the money they contribute.
“Every tax dollar comes from someone's hard work. That should matter every time a decision is made... Responsible spending means setting clear priorities, reducing waste, looking for efficiencies, and making sure residents can see real value from the money they contribute.”

(a few sentences)

Source: Dan Caswell campaign website — priorities · October 1, 2026

Think we’ve got this wrong?

Rebecca Mello

Facebook: RebeccaMelloInstagram: rebeccactually

Stop the burden of taxes on constituents; pledges a governance review and a financial review, and to look after Huntsville first.

  • Pledges to stop the burden of taxes on constituents.
  • Promises a governance review and a financial review.
  • Says the town must look after its own first.
Show their words & source (a few sentences)
“We need to start listening more, be more transparent, and stop the burden of taxes on all our constituents. So, I'm ready to do a governance review, a financial review, and look after us first.”

Source: Sept 9, 2026 mayoral meet-and-greet (YourTV Muskoka) — candidate's own remarks (1:04) · September 11, 2026

This candidate has spoken about this issue more than once. Each statement is shown with its own source.

Priorities: disciplined fiscal management, better roads and infrastructure, transparent accountable government, thoughtful growth; plus health care, attainable housing, youth opportunities.

  • Disciplined fiscal management, better roads and infrastructure.
  • Transparent and accountable government; thoughtful growth protecting Huntsville's character.
  • Strengthen health care, expand attainable housing, create youth opportunities.
“Over the next four years, my priorities are disciplined fiscal management, better roads and infrastructure, transparent and accountable government, and thoughtful growth that protects Huntsville's character. I will continue working to strengthen health care, expand attainable housing and create more opportunities for our young people to build their futures here.”

(reported remarks)

Source: What mayoral candidates in Muskoka's three largest towns say they want to change (MuskokaRegion) · September 28, 2026

Year-round departmental budget committees (parks and rec, finance, operations) with the mayor on all, going line by line.

  • Replace committee-of-the-whole budgeting with departmental committees.
  • Mayor would sit on all committees; they meet all year, not just year-end.
  • Go through budgets line by line to find savings.
“The next stage is to go to a committee structure as opposed to a committee of the whole. The committee structure has each department having, and the mayor would sit on all of these committees, parks and rec, finance, operations. They'd be meeting all year, not at the end of the year. And they'd be going through line by line.”

(a few sentences)

Source: Sept 17, 2026 mayoral debate, Algonquin Theatre — candidate's own remarks (0:35:33) · September 17, 2026

Run the town like a corporation: council as a board of directors, taxpayers as shareholders; opposes council pay raises.

  • Focus on needs over wants to keep property taxes under control.
  • Says council should act like a board of directors respecting taxpayers as shareholders.
  • Voted against council pay raises (record on his /history page).
“Focus on needs and not wants to make sure that we keep our property taxes under control. Run the town like a true corporation where council acts like a board of directors, respecting the needs of the shareholders, which are the taxpayers and residents.”

(several paragraphs)

Source: Scott Morrison campaign website — Fiscal

Think we’ve got this wrong?

Roads, infrastructure and the basics

Will the things I use every day actually get fixed?

This candidate has spoken about this issue more than once. Each statement is shown with its own source.

Continue investing in roads and municipal services for current and future residents.

  • Frames infrastructure investment as serving both today’s residents and future growth.
“Continue investing in roads, infrastructure, and municipal services to support both current residents and future growth.”

(one sentence)

Source: Dan Armour campaign website — Platform · September 13, 2026

Brendale Square is a 100-plus-year flood zone; protect annually flooded residential areas (River Cove, Glen Acres, Southdale) instead.

  • Says Brendale Square has been a flood zone for over 100 years and will keep flooding.
  • Names River Cove, Glen Acres and Southdale Drive as annually flooded residential areas.
  • 'We should be saving infrastructure, not saving a couple of bars.'
“As you all know, that's a flood zone. It has been a flood zone for well over 100 years, and it's going to continue to flood. We have areas in Huntsville, like River Cove or Glen Acres, or even Southdale Drive, that floods annually and stops people from getting into their homes and out of their homes. That's where we should be investing our money. We should be saving infrastructure, not saving a couple of bars.”

(several paragraphs)

Source: Sept 17, 2026 mayoral debate, Algonquin Theatre — candidate's own remarks (1:20:49) · September 17, 2026

Think we’ve got this wrong?

This candidate has spoken about this issue more than once. Each statement is shown with its own source.

Maintain what the Town already owns before starting anything new.

  • Frames maintenance of existing assets as the priority over new projects.
  • Raised alongside respecting taxpayers and healthcare readiness at the Chamber event.
“We want to invest in some of the items that we already have before we look at new stuff”

(reported remarks)

Source: Huntsville Doppler — Mayoral candidates make their pitch at Chamber meet and greet (event 9 Sep 2026) · September 11, 2026

Brendale Square flooding: two inoperative Big East River dams (since 2006) are a provincial matter needing action; flooding will continue regardless of land-level work.

  • Brendale Square has been a flood zone for over 100 years.
  • Two Big East River dams inoperative since 2006 are a provincial matter needing action.
  • Flooding will continue regardless of what is done to the land.
“These are provincial things that we need to start working with … they've been not in operation since 2006, and we had a huge event in 2009, we had another huge event 2013, another huge event. This is going to continue to happen, it doesn't matter what we do to the land.”

(reported remarks)

Source: Huntsville mayoral debate: strong-mayor powers, flooding, welcoming community (Huntsville Forester) · September 18, 2026

Respect the taxpayer and healthcare readiness; invest in maintaining existing infrastructure before looking at new items.

  • Names respect of the taxpayer and healthcare readiness as priorities.
  • Wants to maintain the infrastructure the town already has.
  • Says to invest in existing items before looking at new ones.
“Some of the things that are very important to me is respect of the taxpayer healthc care readiness and you know maintaining the infrastructure we have. We want to invest in some of the items that we already have before we look at new stuff”

(a few sentences)

Source: Sept 9, 2026 mayoral meet-and-greet (YourTV Muskoka) — candidate's own remarks (2:24) · September 11, 2026

Treats roads, sidewalks, trails and facilities as daily life, not line items.

  • Maintain what exists before adding new.
  • Practical improvements residents can see and feel.
“Residents deserve roads, trails, parks, sidewalks, facilities, and services they can count on.”

(several paragraphs)

Source: Dan Caswell campaign website — My Priorities · September 13, 2026

Roads-first plan: 10 initial roads with published dates and costs; work with the province on two idle dams (Big East River, West Harry Lake).

  • Establish 10 roads to begin with, with published start dates, completion dates and costs.
  • Tackle flooding upstream: two non-operational dams (Big East River, West Harry Lake, idle since 2006).
  • Says the dams are provincial and need provincial cooperation.
“One thing that I wanna come up with is the roads first approach. We're gonna establish 10 roads to begin with and with those 10 roads, we'll tell you when we're gonna start the work, when it's gonna be completed and how much it's gonna cost. There are two dams that are very critical for our area that are not in operation. One is the distress dam that's on the Big East River and the other one's at West Harry Lake. These are provincial things that we need to start working with the province. They've been not in operation since 2006. When the water's coming out of the Algonquin Park, there's nothing stopping it. There's nothing managing it. That's where we need to start.”

(several paragraphs)

Source: Sept 17, 2026 mayoral debate, Algonquin Theatre — candidate's own remarks (0:22:41, 1:23:07) · September 17, 2026

Think we’ve got this wrong?

Rebecca Mello

Facebook: RebeccaMelloInstagram: rebeccactually

Names roads and public access to the lakes as needing attention.

  • Stated briefly, without further detail, in her announcement.
  • A commenter on the article asked her to specify which roads and what kind of water access; the article does not record an answer.
Show their words & source (reported remarks)
“Our roads and public access to lakes also need attention”

Source: Huntsville Doppler — Rebecca Mello is also running to become Huntsville's next mayor · May 5, 2026

Promises to end the annual flooding that hits Brendale Square businesses.

  • Says he has already done preliminary work and had discussions with the landowner.
  • Planning reports have repeatedly identified extensive remediation and flood mitigation as prerequisites to redevelopment.
  • Also cites what he describes as a 65 per cent increase in road spending during the current term.
Show their words & source (reported remarks)
“Every year this happens, and I can tell you that I've done some work and I'm ready to fix it. I am going to fix it”

Source: Huntsville Doppler — Morrison pledges to end flooding at Brendale Square during mayoral campaign launch · May 21, 2026

How council works

How would this person actually govern?

This candidate has spoken about this issue more than once. Each statement is shown with its own source.

Consensus first; would use strong-mayor powers only if necessary to move Huntsville forward, not merely because he has the authority.

  • First approach is always to work with council and yield a consensus.
  • Would use the powers only if necessary to move Huntsville forward.
“First approach would always be to work with council, listen to our residents, and yield a consensus before any decision is made.”

(reported remarks)

Source: Huntsville mayoral debate: strong-mayor powers, flooding, welcoming community (Huntsville Forester) · September 18, 2026

Back-to-basics governing — listen, communicate, be transparent; the biggest difference he offers is how the town is governed.

  • Meaningful engagement and open communication.
  • Says residents should understand where tax money goes before it is raised.
  • Frames 12 years of council experience as the reason the main change he offers is how the town is governed.
  • Pledges listening to residents, better communication, transparent finances, a responsive Town Hall.
“Ensure residents have a strong voice through meaningful engagement, open communication, and transparent decision-making. The biggest difference will be how we govern. I want Council to get back to the basics—listening to residents, communicating better, being transparent about our finances and making sure every tax dollar is being spent responsibly. I've spent my career serving this community. I want to bring that same approach to the Mayor's office—people first, common sense, accountability and getting back to basics.”

(several paragraphs)

Source: Dan Armour campaign website — Platform · September 13, 2026

Back-to-basics: people first, listening, an open and accountable town hall; responsible spending, affordable housing, reliable infrastructure, environmental protection.

  • Putting people first, listening to residents, a more open and accountable town hall.
  • Responsible spending, affordable housing, reliable infrastructure, environmental protection.
  • Honest leadership, common sense, working together.
“My priorities are about getting Huntsville back to basics: putting people first, listening to residents, and making town hall more open and accountable. We need responsible spending, affordable housing, reliable infrastructure, and protection of our environment. I believe in honest leadership, common sense, and working together to build Huntsville's future.”

(reported remarks)

Source: What mayoral candidates in Muskoka's three largest towns say they want to change (MuskokaRegion) · September 28, 2026

Think we’ve got this wrong?

This candidate has spoken about this issue more than once. Each statement is shown with its own source.

Says good leadership starts with listening, including to people who disagree.

  • Wants to hear from residents who see things differently.
  • Residents should feel heard before decisions are made, not after.
“Residents deserve to feel heard before decisions are made, not after.”

(several paragraphs)

Source: Dan Caswell campaign website — My Priorities · September 13, 2026

Lead through collaboration: meet successful councillors on their goals, align with the CAO, avoid strong-mayor powers.

  • Would immediately meet the successful councillors to learn their one-year and four-year goals.
  • Would sit down with the CAO to align council and staff.
  • Prefers collaboration over strong-mayor powers.
“I look at it as it being collaboration. If successful as your next mayor, I would instantly call the other successful candidates and we would sit down. I want to know exactly what their goals are in the next year, in the next four years. I would take that even further and with our CAO, I'd sit down, talk to her as well.”

(a few sentences)

Source: Sept 17, 2026 mayoral debate, Algonquin Theatre — candidate's own remarks (0:54:32) · September 17, 2026

Wants Huntsville to have a bigger voice with the district and work in harmony with the provincially appointed district chair.

  • Wants Huntsville to have a bigger voice with the district.
  • Notes the district chair is appointed from the province.
  • Wants to work alongside that chair so town and district work in harmony.
“having a bigger voice with the district. Right now the the district is having their chair appointed from the province and I want to have a big voice work along with that chair so we Huntsville and uh the district work in harmony.”

(a few sentences)

Source: Sept 9, 2026 mayoral meet-and-greet (YourTV Muskoka) — candidate's own remarks (2:35) · September 11, 2026

Huntsville should lead important conversations, not react after decisions are already made.

  • Lead important conversations rather than reacting after decisions are made.
“I believe Huntsville should be leading important conversations, not reacting after decisions are already made.”

(one sentence)

Source: Dan Caswell campaign website — priorities · October 1, 2026

Think we’ve got this wrong?

Rebecca Mello

Facebook: RebeccaMelloInstagram: rebeccactually

This candidate has spoken about this issue more than once. Each statement is shown with its own source.

Frames her approach as bringing people of different ages and backgrounds together.

  • Says interdisciplinary and intergenerational connection is central to her platform.
  • Is the youngest candidate in the mayoral race.
“Finally, bringing people together to learn from each other, that's where our strength lies. This is what I will focus on.”

(reported remarks)

Source: Huntsville Doppler — Rebecca Mello is also running to become Huntsville's next mayor · May 5, 2026

Says her campaign has been shaped by conversations with residents.

  • Told the Chamber meet-and-greet she wants to bring younger and older generations together and learn from their different experiences.
  • Doppler also reported she emphasised protecting Huntsville's natural environment and water and building a community attractive to families and retirees; that was the reporter's summary, not a direct quotation, so it is not shown as her words.
“Every person has a different story, and every person is showing me a different part of what Huntsville is made of”

(reported remarks)

Source: Huntsville Doppler — Mayoral candidates make their pitch at Chamber meet and greet (event 9 Sep 2026) · September 11, 2026

Treats strong-mayor powers as a tool she would not plan to fall back on, preferring collaborative council work.

  • Would not enter office planning to fall back on strong-mayor powers.
  • Prefers working collaboratively with the rest of council.
“I think that Strong Mayor Powers is a tool that can be used when appropriate, but I would not enter the role having that in the back of my mind that if I want to do something and most people don't agree with me, I have these powers to fall back on. I think that there's no need to use Strong Mayor Powers if I'm able to work collaboratively with the rest of the council.”

(a few sentences)

Source: Sept 17, 2026 mayoral debate, Algonquin Theatre — candidate's own remarks (0:56:02) · September 17, 2026

Pitches a new perspective against incumbent experience: "You haven't seen what I can do."

  • Says Huntsville needs a new perspective and a new way to look at things.
  • Contrasts incumbents' record with her untested potential.
“Huntsville needs a new perspective, a new way to look at things. You've seen what they can do because they've been doing it this entire time. You haven't seen what I can do.”

(a few sentences)

Source: Rebecca Mello's Facebook reel (Aug 18, 2026) · August 18, 2026

Politics should never be about money; public service means community trust and human connection.

  • Says politics and elections should never be about who has the most to invest.
  • Frames public service as community trust; nothing should trump human connection.
“Politics should never be about money. Elections should never be about who has the most to invest. Being a public servant means the community trusts you to represent them. Nothing should trump human connection.”

(a few sentences)

Source: Rebecca Mello's Facebook reel caption (Sept 21, 2026) · September 21, 2026

Speaks to young voters: representation is attainable; her generation is Huntsville's future.

  • Says representation is attainable for once.
  • Her generation represents the future of Huntsville, not the past.
  • Notes young people are often disinterested in elections and voting.
“Representation is attainable for once, and it's time for the generation leading Huntsville to the future to care about this! I think many times young people, young professionals, young families, young couples are disinterested in involving themselves in elections and voting. Remember our generation represents the future of Huntsville not the past.”

(a few sentences)

Source: Rebecca Mello's Facebook reel — "Day 62 of running for mayor" (July 6, 2026) · July 6, 2026

Back-to-basics platform: listen more, be more transparent, starting with a governance review.

  • Calls her platform going back to the basics.
  • Says the town must listen more and be more transparent.
  • Proposes a governance review.
“My platform is fairly simple. It's going back to the basics. We need to start looking after our own. We need to start listening more, be more transparent”

(a few sentences)

Source: Sept 9, 2026 mayoral meet-and-greet (YourTV Muskoka) — candidate's own remarks (1:04) · September 11, 2026

Strong-mayor powers are a tool for appropriate use, but she would not enter the role planning to fall back on them against the majority.

  • Powers are a tool for appropriate use.
  • Would not enter the role planning to fall back on them when most people disagree.
“I think that going into the role as somebody that's been chosen by the people of Huntsville to represent and to serve them, I would not enter the role having that in the back of my mind that if I want to do something and most people don't agree with me, I have these powers to fall back on.”

(reported remarks)

Source: Huntsville mayoral debate: strong-mayor powers, flooding, welcoming community (Huntsville Forester) · September 18, 2026

Running to represent the voices of Huntsville residents and serve their best interests; values community and bringing people together.

  • Values community, bringing people together, combining strengths for a common goal.
  • Her role is to represent the voices of Huntsville and serve their best interests.
“My name is Rebecca, and I am running for mayor of Huntsville. I value community, bringing people together and combining our strengths to work for a common goal. My role is to represent the voices of Huntsville, and I will serve my community and represent their best interests.”

(reported remarks)

Source: What mayoral candidates in Muskoka's three largest towns say they want to change (MuskokaRegion) · September 28, 2026

Think we’ve got this wrong?

This candidate has spoken about this issue more than once. Each statement is shown with its own source.

Public input needs informed residents; commits to video updates, podcast summaries, town halls, a Residents' Advisory Panel.

  • Commits to video updates, podcast summaries, town halls and a Residents' Advisory Panel.
  • Pushed a washroom item out of closed session into the open.
  • Challenging the District's six-month recording-retention practice.
“Public input only works when people have the information they need to make an informed judgment.”

(several paragraphs)

Source: Scott Morrison campaign website — Transparency

Would publish video and audio from every meeting and answer his own phone.

  • Names podcasts of meetings and a video from the mayor after every meeting.
  • Frames accountability as being personally reachable by phone.
“The biggest thing is transparency: podcasts at the meeting to go out to the public, videos from the mayor after every meeting, so you know what we discussed and why, and an accountability where you can call me anytime and I'll answer the phone”

(reported remarks)

Source: Huntsville Doppler — Mayoral candidates make their pitch at Chamber meet and greet (event 9 Sep 2026) · September 11, 2026

Hopes never to hear "strong mayor powers" again; lead as a consensus builder so they never need using.

  • Plans on avoiding strong-mayor powers at all costs.
  • The key is being a strong leader and consensus builder.
  • The mayor should lead so the powers never need using.
“I personally hope that this is the last time I hear the word strong mayor powers because I plan on avoiding using it at all costs. I think the key is to be a strong leader, be a consensus builder. I think the mayor needs to lead so you never ever have to use strong mayor powers.”

(a few sentences)

Source: Sept 17, 2026 mayoral debate, Algonquin Theatre — candidate's own remarks (0:53:37) · September 17, 2026

Reformed the planning process to cut red tape while protecting what matters; proposes a meeting podcast, post-meeting mayor videos, and direct accountability: call anytime and he will answer.

  • Says he reformed the planning process to reduce red tape while protecting what matters.
  • Proposes a podcast of each meeting released to the public.
  • Proposes videos from the mayor after every meeting explaining what was discussed and why.
  • Offers direct accountability: residents can call him anytime and he will answer.
“I uh tried to reform the planning process to make um the red tape go away a little bit while still protecting the stuff that matters Biggest thing is transparency. podcast of the meeting to go out to the public, videos from the mayor after every meeting so you know what we discussed and why and an accountability where you can call me anytime and I'll answer the phone. That's my plan.”

(several paragraphs)

Source: Sept 9, 2026 mayoral meet-and-greet (YourTV Muskoka) — candidate's own remarks (1:25, 2:10) · September 11, 2026

Would avoid using strong-mayor powers; a strong mayor builds consensus among the nine elected, not one.

  • Would avoid using strong-mayor powers at all costs.
  • A strong leader builds consensus — nine people were elected, not one.
“I think the key is to be a strong leader, be a consensus builder … I would hate, as a mayor, to look at people around the table that you guys elected to get to that table and not think of the fact that it was nine people, not one.”

(reported remarks)

Source: Huntsville mayoral debate: strong-mayor powers, flooding, welcoming community (Huntsville Forester) · September 18, 2026

Introduced AI opportunities to district and town — implement AI for better, more efficient public services, automate routine workflows, save taxpayer money; "I work for the people who pay my salary — you, the taxpayers."

  • Implement AI to deliver better, more efficient public services and automate routine workflows.
  • Save taxpayer money through AI-driven efficiencies.
  • I work for the people who pay my salary — you, the taxpayers.
“Introduced the opportunities AI provides to district and town — starting to implement AI to deliver better, more efficient public services, automate routine workflows, and save taxpayer money. I work for the people who pay my salary — you, the taxpayers. I will always do the right thing for the taxpayer, no matter who is on the other end of the line.”

(a few sentences)

Source: Scott Morrison campaign website — history · October 1, 2026

Council should decide for future generations, not chase quick wins within a four-year term.

  • Decisions that consider future generations at all times.
  • Stop trying to get quick wins during a 4-year term.
“We need a council that is willing to make decisions that consider future generations at all times... trying to get quick wins during your 4 year term has to stop.”

(a few sentences)

Source: Climate Action Muskoka candidate survey — Scott Morrison (candidate's own answers) · January 1, 2022

Think we’ve got this wrong?

Growth, development and community character

How much should Huntsville grow, and where?

Supports growth that protects Huntsville’s character and quality of life.

  • Frames growth as something to be managed rather than stopped.
Show their words & source (one sentence)
“Support growth that strengthens our community while protecting the character, environment, and quality of life that make Huntsville special.”

Source: Dan Armour campaign website — Platform · September 13, 2026

This candidate has spoken about this issue more than once. Each statement is shown with its own source.

Stricter facade and vegetation-buffer rules for major developments and corporate stores to protect small-town charm.

  • Small-town charm starts with stricter facade rules.
  • Strict vegetation barrier rules for major developments.
  • Cites Walmart as a missed opportunity to require a more Muskoka-like look.
“I think small-town charm starts with stricter facade rules. I think small-town charm starts with strict vegetation barrier rules. You have a place like Walmart which is great for our community but then why wouldn't we push back when it came in to have it look more of a Muskoka like or why wouldn't we have a nice vegetation barrier going around it so it's not just this big gray store.”

(a few sentences)

Source: Sept 17, 2026 mayoral debate, Algonquin Theatre — candidate's own remarks (1:28:36) · September 17, 2026

Frames decisions in terms of what the next generation inherits.

  • Responsible growth and long-term planning.
  • Protecting Huntsville’s character while making room for growth.
“Planning for future generations means protecting what makes Huntsville feel like home while making room for responsible growth.”

(several paragraphs)

Source: Dan Caswell campaign website — My Priorities · September 13, 2026

Pressing for clarity on the Florence Street development — unit counts, height, fees, studies — and correcting his own timeline error.

  • Asks what is proposed vs. approved vs. changed on the Muskoka Community Land Trust Florence Street development.
  • Presses for unit counts, height, fees and studies.
  • Publicly corrected a timeline error in his own video.
“I believe residents should be able to understand what is being proposed, what has been approved and what has changed along the way. I believe accountability starts with being willing to correct the record when something is wrong.”

(several paragraphs)

Source: Dan Caswell campaign website — Florence Street · September 15, 2026

Think we’ve got this wrong?

Rebecca Mello

Facebook: RebeccaMelloInstagram: rebeccactually

This candidate has spoken about this issue more than once. Each statement is shown with its own source.

Growth is not the enemy — unplanned growth is; put preventative measures for infrastructure, climate resilience and healthcare in place first.

  • 'Growth is not the enemy. Unplanned growth is the enemy.'
  • Growth will happen whether planned or not.
  • Prepare with preventative measures for infrastructure, climate resilience and healthcare.
“What I believe is that growth is not the enemy. Huntsville is going to grow whether we plan for it or not. I think that unplanned growth is the enemy that we should be scared of. As I mentioned before, I believe that growth is inevitable and Huntsville is going to continue to grow whether we plan for it or not and the best way that we can be prepared for that growth is by implementing preventative measures and tools to prepare in advance, whether that means infrastructure or climate resilience or healthcare.”

(several paragraphs)

Source: Sept 17, 2026 mayoral debate, Algonquin Theatre — candidate's own remarks (0:37:41, 1:02:05) · September 17, 2026

Make Huntsville's outdoor-recreation heritage a deliberate selling point to attract young families.

  • Wants the town's outdoor recreational heritage celebrated and prioritized.
  • Frames outdoor recreation as Huntsville's winning point over other Ontario towns.
  • Aims to attract young families choosing where to raise children.
“It's time to focus and celebrate the rich outdoor recreational heritage Huntsville has and make it a priority in attracting young families. Outdoor recreation should be an additional winning point Huntsville has above many other towns in Ontario. I plan to focus on that. Because we want to attract young families to come and choose Huntsville to be the place where they're going to raise their children.”

(a few sentences)

Source: Rebecca Mello's Facebook reel — "Day 58 of running for mayor" (June 30, 2026) · June 30, 2026

Think we’ve got this wrong?

This candidate has spoken about this issue more than once. Each statement is shown with its own source.

Says he tried to cut planning red tape while keeping the protections that matter.

  • Frames planning reform as a balance rather than deregulation.
  • Cites it as part of his record in the current term.
“I tried to reform the planning process to make the red tape go away a little bit while still protecting the stuff that matters”

(reported remarks)

Source: Huntsville Doppler — Mayoral candidates make their pitch at Chamber meet and greet (event 9 Sep 2026) · September 11, 2026

Protect community character while keeping Huntsville affordable for families, businesses and young people.

  • Frames his platform as protecting community character and affordability together.
  • Names families, businesses, young people and value for taxpayers.
“I want to protect the character of our community while ensuring it remains a place where families can afford to live, businesses can succeed, young people can build a future and residents receive real value from their local government.”

(a few sentences)

Source: Scott Morrison campaign website — Meet Scott

Opposes provincial intrusion into local planning via Bill 98; the height/density bylaw was ordered to protect Huntsville's character, with checks on where big buildings go.

  • Calls Bill 98 one of the most significant planning alterations in provincial history.
  • Opposes the province sticking its nose into local planning checks and balances.
  • The bylaw protects Huntsville's character: big buildings where justified, not where they aren't.
“Bill 98 that's come out is considered one of the most significant planning alterations in provincial history, and right now, unfortunately, parts of our bylaw would contravene that legislation. I don't like that the province is sticking its nose into our planning process where we're trying to put checks and balances in to protect the character of our town.”

(reported remarks)

Source: Huntsville council approves bylaw update allowing taller, denser housing (BayToday/Huntsville Forester) · June 10, 2026

Think we’ve got this wrong?

Housing and affordability

Can people who work here afford to live here?

This candidate has spoken about this issue more than once. Each statement is shown with its own source.

Would look at cutting development charges on qualifying rental projects.

  • Supports purpose-built rental housing.
  • Would explore reducing or eliminating development charges on qualifying rental projects.
“Support the development of purpose-built rental housing by exploring opportunities to reduce or eliminate development charges on qualifying rental projects.”

(one sentence)

Source: Dan Armour campaign website — Platform · September 13, 2026

Support purpose-built rental housing by exploring reducing or eliminating development charges on qualifying rental projects.

  • Explore reducing or eliminating development charges on qualifying rental projects.
  • Support the development of purpose-built rental housing.
“Support the development of purpose-built rental housing by exploring opportunities to reduce or eliminate development charges on qualifying rental projects.”

(one sentence)

Source: Elect Dan Armour — Mayor of Huntsville · October 3, 2026

Think we’ve got this wrong?

Rebecca Mello

Facebook: RebeccaMelloInstagram: rebeccactually

Provide different housing options and remove unnecessary red tape and barriers.

  • Supports providing different options for housing.
  • Wants unnecessary red tape and barriers removed.
Show their words & source (one sentence)
“I believe in providing different options for housing and also removing unnecessary red tape and unnecessary barriers that get in the way of making that possible.”

Source: Sept 17, 2026 mayoral debate, Algonquin Theatre — candidate's own remarks (0:08:59) · September 17, 2026

This candidate has spoken about this issue more than once. Each statement is shown with its own source.

Brendale Square's residential side should mix market rental and affordable housing, including seniors and Community Living clients.

  • Wants Brendale Square residential to mix market rental and affordable housing.
  • Housing should suit seniors, Community Living clients and others needing appropriate options.
  • Also pushes smaller rural severances and pre-approved additional dwelling units.
“The residential component of Brendale Square should be equally thoughtful — a mixture of market rental and affordable housing, with opportunities to create housing suited to seniors, Community Living clients and others who need appropriate options.”

(a few sentences)

Source: Scott Morrison campaign website — Housing

Proponent of tiny homes and affordable alternatives — if someone needs 500 sq ft, don't force much larger homes.

  • Champions tiny homes as an affordable-housing win.
  • If someone only needs 500 square feet, don't force much larger homes.
“I am also a strong proponent of tiny homes and other affordable alternatives... If someone only needs 500 square feet why are we forcing them to live in much larger homes?”

(a few sentences)

Source: Climate Action Muskoka candidate survey — Scott Morrison (candidate's own answers) · January 1, 2022

Think we’ve got this wrong?

Healthcare and the new hospital

Can I see a doctor, and how will we pay for the new hospital?

This candidate has spoken about this issue more than once. Each statement is shown with its own source.

Town hospital fund established 2024 already past $5 million; will surpass the $10 million local share.

  • Says the Town established a hospital fund in 2024.
  • Claims it is already past $5 million.
  • Says it will surpass the $10 million local share by handover.
“We established a fund in 2024, and we'll well pass $5 million already. And by the time it's turned that money over to the hospital association or the hospital board, we're going to be surpassed our $10 million.”

(a few sentences)

Source: Sept 17, 2026 mayoral debate, Algonquin Theatre — candidate's own remarks (0:25:49) · September 17, 2026

Backs the new hospital and working with community partners on healthcare.

  • Supports efforts to strengthen healthcare services.
  • Notes plans moving forward for a new hospital.
“Support efforts to strengthen healthcare services and continue to work with community partners as plans move forward for a new hospital.”

(one sentence)

Source: Dan Armour campaign website — Platform · September 13, 2026

Think we’ve got this wrong?

This candidate has spoken about this issue more than once. Each statement is shown with its own source.

Wants a dedicated fund built now for Huntsville’s $10 million hospital share.

  • Proposes a dedicated Huntsville Community Hospital Fund.
  • Targets the $10 million local share he says will be required.
  • Wants milestones published so residents can see how prepared the Town is.
  • Says the money should come from efficiencies rather than from roads and trails budgets.
“My focus is to support a dedicated Huntsville Community Hospital Fund, focused on preparing for the required $10 million local share.”

(a page or more)

Source: Dan Caswell campaign website — My Priorities · September 13, 2026

Support a dedicated Huntsville Community Hospital Fund for the $10 million local share — be ready before the province moves.

  • A dedicated Huntsville Community Hospital Fund for the $10 million local share.
  • Be ready with the local share when the province moves forward — don't scramble after.
“My focus is to support a dedicated Huntsville Community Hospital Fund, focused on preparing for the required $10 million local share. When the province is ready to move forward with the new hospital, Huntsville needs to be ready with its local share. We cannot wait until that moment arrives and then scramble to find the money.”

(a few sentences)

Source: Dan Caswell for Mayor of Huntsville | 2026 Municipal Election · October 3, 2026

Proposes "office-ready" doctor recruitment: spend the incentive on office space and infrastructure, remove setup burdens.

  • Instead of a cash incentive, fund office space and infrastructure.
  • Remove the setup burdens so doctors start treating patients immediately.
“Office ready means that rather than pay the $80,000 to come into Huntsville, we're gonna take that money and we're gonna find the office space. We're gonna take away all the burdens for them and then they can come in and start working and treating patients all at once.”

(a few sentences)

Source: Sept 17, 2026 mayoral debate, Algonquin Theatre — candidate's own remarks (0:22:17) · September 17, 2026

Think we’ve got this wrong?

Rebecca Mello

Facebook: RebeccaMelloInstagram: rebeccactually

Healthcare access is an economic issue shaping where people live and work; the mayor's role is carrying residents' voice to the province.

  • Frames healthcare accessibility as an economic issue, not just a medical one.
  • Says it shapes where people retire, move, work and raise families.
  • Healthcare is a provincial decision; the mayor's best lever is carrying residents' voice to the province.
Show their words & source (several paragraphs)
“I believe that the next Mayor of Huntsville needs to recognize that healthcare accessibility is not only a medical issue, but it's actually an economic issue. Healthcare accessibility is a distinguishing factor when people are deciding where they're going to retire, where they want to move, where they want to work and have their family and raise their children. Since this is the responsibility of the province, the most effective thing the mayor can do is to carry the voice of the people. The mayor represents the people and that's the best that the mayor, I think, can promise in terms of advancing it because at the end of the day, it's a provincial decision.”

Source: Sept 17, 2026 mayoral debate, Algonquin Theatre — candidate's own remarks (0:08:28, 1:12:43) · September 17, 2026

This candidate has spoken about this issue more than once. Each statement is shown with its own source.

Points to the doctor recruitment program he says he built with Bob Stone.

  • Claims the program has brought almost ten doctors to Huntsville.
  • Says he wants to keep focusing on healthcare in a further term.
  • Note: this is his own account of his record; SmarterVote has not independently verified the number.
“I built the doctor recruitment program with Bob Stone, which has brought us almost ten doctors now”

(reported remarks)

Source: Huntsville Doppler — Mayoral candidates make their pitch at Chamber meet and greet (event 9 Sep 2026) · September 11, 2026

Backs the new hospital; wants Huntsville's needs represented, including exploring local cancer treatment services.

  • Calls the new hospital one of the most important investments in Huntsville's future.
  • Wants to explore bringing some cancer treatment services to Huntsville so residents get more care closer to home.
“The new hospital will be one of the most important investments in Huntsville's future. I will provide strong municipal leadership to make sure Huntsville's needs are clearly represented, including exploring opportunities to bring some cancer treatment services to Huntsville so residents can access more care closer to home.”

(several paragraphs)

Source: Scott Morrison campaign website — Healthcare

Think we’ve got this wrong?

Environment, lakes and dark skies

Who is protecting the lakes and the night sky?

Protect lakes, rivers and forests alongside responsible development.

  • Environmental stewardship paired with responsible development.
Show their words & source (one sentence)
“Protect our lakes, rivers, forests, and natural spaces while promoting responsible development and environmental stewardship.”

Source: Dan Armour campaign website — Platform · September 13, 2026

Rebecca Mello

Facebook: RebeccaMelloInstagram: rebeccactually

This candidate has spoken about this issue more than once. Each statement is shown with its own source.

Protect Huntsville's nature and water assets — the foundation of its appeal as a place to retire and raise a family.

  • Says the town must take care of its nature and water assets.
  • Frames them as the basis for Huntsville becoming known across Canada.
  • Sees them as making Huntsville a place to retire and raise a family.
“We need to take care of our assets, including nature and our water. Like, these are all things that have the potential to become a well-known place in Canada, a place to retire, but also an ideal place to grow your family.”

(a few sentences)

Source: Sept 9, 2026 mayoral meet-and-greet (YourTV Muskoka) — candidate's own remarks (0:30) · September 11, 2026

Calls the lakes, waterfront and nature Huntsville's greatest economic asset; protect them, expand outdoor education and recreation access, prepare for climate resilience.

  • Calls the lakes, waterfront and nature Huntsville's greatest economic asset.
  • Wants outdoor education and recreation accessible to all ages.
  • Says the town must prepare for climate resilience.
“I think that the greatest economic asset that Huntsville has is the lakes, the waterfront, and the nature. I think that's something that's very important and something that we need to protect and take care of. And I believe that making outdoor education and outdoor recreation more accessible to all ages is something that we should look towards and we should work towards. I think we also need to prepare our environment and our town for climate resilience to be ready for what comes our way.”

(several paragraphs)

Source: Sept 17, 2026 mayoral debate, Algonquin Theatre — candidate's own remarks (0:05:58) · September 17, 2026

Think we’ve got this wrong?

Huntsville's place at the District table

Is the two-tier system working for Huntsville, or costing us?

This candidate has spoken about this issue more than once. Each statement is shown with its own source.

Wants a stronger Huntsville voice alongside a District chair now appointed by the Province.

  • Notes the District chair is appointed rather than elected.
  • Frames the goal as Huntsville and the District working in harmony rather than in conflict.
“Right now the District is having their chair appointed from the province, and I want to have a big voice, work along with that chair, so we, Huntsville and the District, work in harmony.”

(reported remarks)

Source: Huntsville Doppler — Mayoral candidates make their pitch at Chamber meet and greet (event 9 Sep 2026) · September 11, 2026

Wants Huntsville leading at the District table rather than reacting.

  • Better communication, less duplication, stronger representation.
  • Argues overlapping services and slow decisions cost residents money.
“Huntsville should not be reacting from the sidelines. We should be leading the conversation.”

(several paragraphs)

Source: Dan Caswell campaign website — My Priorities · September 13, 2026

Think we’ve got this wrong?

Rebecca Mello

Facebook: RebeccaMelloInstagram: rebeccactually

Not reviewed yet. Know something?

Proposed a full review of the development process, including possibly eliminating upper-tier planning.

  • Presented a report proposing a thorough review of the development process.
  • Floats eliminating upper-tier planning to streamline approvals.
  • Frames it as a way to make housing more affordable.
Show their words & source (a few sentences)
“I presented a comprehensive report proposing a thorough review of the development process, including the potential elimination of upper-tier planning to streamline approvals and make housing more affordable.”

Source: Scott Morrison campaign website — Fiscal

Local economy, jobs and downtown

Will there be decent work here, and a downtown worth walking to?

Support local business and attract investment; keep Huntsville affordable, financially responsible, economically strong and environmentally sustainable.

  • Business support, investment attraction, job creation.
  • Framing statement from his homepage message: affordability, financial responsibility, economic strength, environmental sustainability.
Show their words & source (one sentence)
“Support local businesses, attract investment, and encourage economic growth that creates jobs and opportunities. Together, we can build a Huntsville that remains affordable, financially responsible, economically strong, environmentally sustainable, and prepared for the opportunities ahead.”

Source: Dan Armour campaign website — Platform · September 13, 2026

Rebecca Mello

Facebook: RebeccaMelloInstagram: rebeccactually

This candidate has spoken about this issue more than once. Each statement is shown with its own source.

Municipalities must actively challenge provincial policies that carry rural impacts; they are the voice of small-town residents.

  • Municipalities must have a role in advocating for rural impacts to be considered.
  • Calls municipalities the voice of small-town residents.
  • Provincial policies affecting residents and communities need to be challenged.
“I wholeheartedly believe that municipalities must have a role in advocating for rural impacts to be considered. Municipalities are the voice of small-town residents, and provincial policies that affect residents and communities need to be challenged.”

(a few sentences)

Source: Rural Employment Access Ontario 2026 municipal questionnaire — candidate's own answers · September 30, 2026

Focus on helping local businesses scale, and on stopping young adults leaving.

  • Names seasonality and a limited hiring pool as the constraints on local businesses.
  • Frames growing jobs and a sustainable year-round framework as the way to combat what she calls the young adult exodus.
“Areas that require focus include providing support to entrepreneurs and local businesses in scaling while meeting challenges, including seasonality, hiring pool limitations, and housing affordability and availability options.”

(reported remarks)

Source: Huntsville Doppler — Rebecca Mello is also running to become Huntsville's next mayor · May 5, 2026

The mayor's job is clearing barriers for entrepreneurs via public-private partnerships; the town can't do everything.

  • Says the town can't do everything for local business.
  • The mayor should facilitate public-private partnerships.
“I recognize that the town can't do everything. It's my job to facilitate those public private partnerships so that businesses can work together.”

(a few sentences)

Source: Rebecca Mello's Facebook reel (Aug 28, 2026) · August 28, 2026

Small hiring pool and unaffordable housing are the core barriers for Muskoka small businesses.

  • Shadowed a young entrepreneur's home-services business.
  • Names the small hiring pool as a core barrier.
  • Names unaffordable housing as a core barrier.
“I would be happy to spend a day with your business and hear your experience! Hiring pool is so small There's noone to do the work there's nowhere to house them because housing is not”

(a few sentences)

Source: Rebecca Mello's Facebook reel — "Day 52 of running for mayor" (June 24, 2026) · June 24, 2026

Think we’ve got this wrong?

This candidate has spoken about this issue more than once. Each statement is shown with its own source.

Downtown revitalization as a next-term focus.

  • Names revitalizing downtowns as part of the next-term plan.
“that involves revitalizing downtown downtowns”

(one sentence)

Source: Sept 9, 2026 mayoral meet-and-greet (YourTV Muskoka) — candidate's own remarks (1:55) · September 11, 2026

Improve downtown's vacant Empire Lot without burdening the tax levy; Brendale Square via private partnership, grants, fundraising.

  • Goal: make a highly visible part of downtown better without burdening the property tax levy.
  • Brendale Square through private partnership, grants and fundraising.
“The goal is simple: make a highly visible part of downtown better without placing the burden on the property tax levy.”

(a few sentences)

Source: Scott Morrison campaign website — Downtown

Brendale financing: public-private partnership, Town owns only the parking lot and public space, brownfield grants, business-paid "Brendale revitalization fee".

  • Public-private partnership; the town should not own or rent buildings.
  • Town owns only the parking lot and public-space elements (outdoor rink, farmers' market, splash pad).
  • Construction leans on brownfield remediation grants.
  • Operating costs via a business-paid 'Brendale revitalization fee', not tax dollars.
“The most important part is that it's a public-private partnership. I don't want the town to own buildings or rent buildings. The town needs to own the parking lot, and that's it. That's where the outdoor rink would go, the farmer's market would go, the splash pad. There are brownfield remediation grants. I've already approached the owners in that plaza — would you be amenable to something like the Blue Mountain Village fee. So my plan is, I'd call it the Brendale revitalization fee to make sure your tax dollars aren't paying for it.”

(several paragraphs)

Source: Sept 17, 2026 mayoral debate, Algonquin Theatre — candidate's own remarks (1:19:21) · September 17, 2026

Has made redeveloping Brendale Square the centrepiece of his campaign.

  • Launched his campaign on a pledge to redevelop the plaza and end its flooding.
  • Shared a conceptual sketch including green space, a public skating rink, a farmers' market and a splash pad, saying any final design would need community input.
  • Says he believes much of the cost could be covered by outside grants and brownfield redevelopment programs.
  • The site has a history of commercial vacancies, aging infrastructure and contamination from a former landfill and a former gas station.
“It's been way too long that Brendale Square has looked the way it has. It's been a blight on our town. It is one of the most important pieces of our town, and it needs to be better.”

(reported remarks)

Source: Huntsville Doppler — Morrison pledges to end flooding at Brendale Square during mayoral campaign launch · May 21, 2026

Think we’ve got this wrong?

Parks, trails and active transportation

Can you get around safely without a car, and are the parks and trails looked after?

Rebecca Mello

Facebook: RebeccaMelloInstagram: rebeccactually

Huntsville's appeal is a lifestyle integrated with nature; make nature more accessible, integrated and walkable.

  • Says Huntsville's way of life comes from a lifestyle integrated with nature.
  • Wants nature more accessible, integrated and walkable.
  • Frames this as preserving the small-town feel.
Show their words & source (a few sentences)
“The way of life is because the lifestyle is integrated with nature. If we can make the nature more accessible, more integrated, more walkable, we preserve the elements that have always made Huntsville attractive over the years and I think that's a way that we can keep the small town feel.”

Source: Sept 17, 2026 mayoral debate, Algonquin Theatre — candidate's own remarks (1:36:06) · September 17, 2026

This candidate has spoken about this issue more than once. Each statement is shown with its own source.

Championing active living at every age; developers must fund recreational amenities.

  • Backs pump track, mountain bike trails, pickleball, splash pad and a permanent outdoor rink.
  • Developers must fund recreational amenities so they don't land on the tax levy.
“Championing active living for every stage of life — youth spaces, trails, and developer-funded recreational amenities that don't land on the tax levy.”

(a few sentences)

Source: Scott Morrison campaign website — Recreation

Mayoral launch at Canvas Brewery focused heavily on parkland development for families, youth, and seniors.

  • Parkland development for families, youth, and seniors a launch focus.
“Focused heavily on parkland development for families, youth, and seniors.”

(one sentence)

Source: Scott Morrison campaign website — history · October 1, 2026

Think we’ve got this wrong?

Police, fire, emergency services and community safety

Who shows up when you call 911, and do they have what they need?

This candidate has spoken about this issue more than once. Each statement is shown with its own source.

Fire protection, emergency services, roads, winter maintenance and public safety are the foundation, not extras.

  • Lists fire protection, emergency services, roads, winter maintenance and public safety as the foundation of daily life.
  • Frames the basics as non-negotiable, not extras.
“Residents need confidence that the basics are being looked after. Fire protection, emergency services, roads, winter maintenance, public safety, infrastructure, and community services are not extras. They are the foundation of daily life in Huntsville.”

(several paragraphs)

Source: Dan Caswell campaign website — My Priorities

Fire protection, emergency services, roads, winter maintenance, public safety, infrastructure and community services are the foundation of daily life — not extras.

  • Core services are the foundation of daily life, not extras.
  • Fire protection, emergency services, roads, winter maintenance, public safety, infrastructure, community services.
“Fire protection, emergency services, roads, winter maintenance, public safety, infrastructure, and community services are not extras. They are the foundation of daily life in Huntsville.”

(a few sentences)

Source: Dan Caswell campaign website — priorities · October 1, 2026

Think we’ve got this wrong?

Rebecca Mello

Facebook: RebeccaMelloInstagram: rebeccactually

Not reviewed yet. Know something?

Transit and getting around without a car

Can you get where you need to go if you do not drive?

Something wrong here?

Candidates and members of the public can both report a correction. Corrections from candidates about their own positions are handled first.

Report a correction →